I am posting a mail from a fellow group member Poornima Burte. which throws some light in this burning issue
Hi
I feel that reservations of any kind are a surface level solution for problems that are more deep rooted.
They are like distributing free medicines to a population that lacks good sanitation and hygiene. Of course the free medication is required to save lives on an immediate level. But it is no long-term solution. People will still keep falling sick. Its only when they receive clean drinking water and live in hygienic surroundings that the problem will go away.
Its the same with education. If people produce five children because they are not sure how many will live to become adults and so that they can have five pairs of hands to earn money for the family which is on the brink of starvation, it is ridiculous to expect them to value school education even if there are reservations!
If very serious measures are taken to obliterate caste biases and employment with decent remuneration is given to all who are in a physical capacity to work, good quality schools with teachers are available at walking distance from home, education will not remain the privilege of a select few.
And consider this! In Bombay, two thirds of the population is crowded in 5 percent of the available land while the more richer one third is occupying 95% of the land. Why not have reservation here as well? But how many of us richer ones will like to shift into a crammed space and make do with one hour of community tap water? The problem is that of urban over crowding and reserving of land is not the solution. The solution lies elsewhere.. probably in decentralizing employment opportunities or strengthening the village economy to avoid mass migrations.
Its high time that our government, and we as youth realize this and take positive steps to tackle the base level issues. Of course this is a difficult and more time consuming path. Till then we have to accept surface level solutions like a package with also includes some rich OBCs getting medical seats through reservations!
The ancestors of today's SC/ST/OBCs were oppressed. Nobody is denying this, but turning the tables and now oppressing forward casts/higher caste people for an accident of their birth is quite ridiculous.
4 Comments:
Hi,
I've put this logo and the poem on my blogs. Please check.
http://soney.blogspot.com/
http://soney-2.blogspot.com/
-suniti
I am posting a mail from a fellow group member Poornima Burte. which throws some light in this burning issue
Hi
I feel that reservations of any kind are a surface
level solution for problems that are more deep
rooted.
They are like distributing free medicines to a
population that lacks good sanitation and hygiene. Of
course the free medication is required to save lives
on an immediate level. But it is no long-term
solution. People will still keep falling sick. Its
only when they receive clean drinking water and live
in hygienic surroundings that the problem will go
away.
Its the same with education. If people produce five
children because they are not sure how many will live
to become adults and so that they can have five pairs
of hands to earn money for the family which is on the
brink of starvation, it is ridiculous to expect them
to value school education even if there are
reservations!
If very serious measures are taken to obliterate caste
biases and employment with decent remuneration is
given to all who are in a physical capacity to work,
good quality schools with teachers are available at
walking distance from home, education will not remain
the privilege of a select few.
And consider this! In Bombay, two thirds of the
population is crowded in 5 percent of the available
land while the more richer one third is occupying 95%
of the land. Why not have reservation here as well?
But how many of us richer ones will like to shift
into a crammed space and make do with one hour of
community tap water? The problem is that of urban over
crowding and reserving of land is not the solution.
The solution lies elsewhere.. probably in
decentralizing employment opportunities or
strengthening the village economy to avoid mass
migrations.
Its high time that our government, and we as youth
realize this and take positive steps to tackle the
base level issues. Of course this is a difficult and
more time consuming path. Till then we have to accept
surface level solutions like a package with also
includes some rich OBCs getting medical seats
through reservations!
Cheers
Poornima Burte
NID
1993-98
The ancestors of today's SC/ST/OBCs were oppressed. Nobody is denying this, but turning the
tables and now oppressing forward casts/higher caste people for an accident of their birth is quite ridiculous.
It reminds me of Hitler who had SWASTIKA as his logo…
Keep it up… good job…
Post a Comment
<< Home